Coffee House

Mental health: Government’s commitment doesn’t match its rhetoric

24 June 2014

Professor Sue Bailey, the outgoing President of the Royal College of Psychiatry, has described mental health services in England as a ‘car crash’. Although the language may be alarmist Professor Bailey’s concerns deserve to be taken seriously by all those who care about mental health provision in our country.

The truth is that while politicians are much more comfortable talking about mental health than ever before, too often the ambitious rhetoric is ahead of the reality. Of most concern is the decision by NHS England, set against a background of pledged ‘parity of esteem’, to set the price deflator for mental health and community trusts at 1.8 per cent compared to 1.5 per cent for acute hospital trusts. These variations sound small but they make a considerable difference. Naturally, there are sound arguments for driving efficiencies into the NHS but, in common with the past thirty plus years, these are hitting mental health services harder, which are already starting from a lower funding base. Indeed, NHS England’s decision and the seeming impotence of government to challenge that decision is a perfect example of why we need more politics in the NHS and not less. It defies credibility that we in government and parliament think it is a good idea to abrogate responsibility for £100 billion of taxpayers’ money. Our elected representatives and democratic institutions are meant to ensure that publicly funded bodies are accountable to those that they serve; in the case of the NHS we have deliberately lost sight of this.


At a more granular level, the closure of mental health beds over the past decade is now giving cause for real concern. Looking after people in the community is a wholly desirable aspiration but there will always be occasions when someone is so ill that he or she will need to be cared for in a specialist setting, near their family and friends. Sadly, it remains too often the case that people are transported up to two or three hundred miles from their home in search of a bed. Not just adults but children too. This is simply unacceptable and must stop now. I recently chaired an event at the House of Commons and learnt of one family, unable to secure a hospital bed, being offered a place at a young offenders’ institution for their disturbed and distressed son. Understandably, the family refused this offer.

But it is not all doom and gloom. In my own county of Hertfordshire, we have an enlightened mental health trust and new facilities are being opened. Also, like so many other parts of the country, we are blessed with fantastic mental health professionals. We need to value them and their work. My concern is that this is not always the case. The recent decision around the payment or, as it turned out to be, the non-payment of the 1 per cent pay increase was a managerial error of judgement. It created bad feeling at a time when our political energies would have been better focused on building morale.

Charles Walker is Conservative MP for Broxbourne

More Spectator for less. Subscribe and receive 12 issues delivered for just £12, with full web and app access. Join us now.

  • Dennise Williams

    There is nothing remotely good about mental health services in Hertfordshire. Just mastership of presentation and a degree of spin which would make Alistair Campbell blush.

  • Smithersjones2013

    Why is it Tory MP’s are experts in superficial puerile whining (like this) and hopeless at coming up with credible and workable plans and solutions.

    Clearly Walker wants investment on mental health but where is the money to come from given the public finances are still a mess and who will lose out as a result?

    Walker must do better than this drivel……..

  • kyalami

    There are substantial amounts of money to be saved in the NHS because there’s a lot of wastage

  • dado_trunking

    The odd punter on here will wonder why the Liverpool Care Pathway does not find the minimal resources required to include Suarez.

  • HookesLaw

    Its sad but the govt inherited a massive public sector deficit on taking office and the NHS budget was effectively frozen in real terms and the govt adopted Labour’s 2010 election manifesto commitment to find 20 billion of savings over 4 years.
    The guardian tells me that the mental health budget is 13% of the overall NHS budget. The last govt report I can find, which repeats its commitment to treating mental health, says it was 11% in 2010.

    As it is mental health is the biggest single expenditure in the NHS – followed by circulation problems (editors please note) and cancer.
    Interestingly the NHS spends 2% of its budget on what it terms ‘healthy individuals’.

    • davidraynes

      It is interesting that Charles Walker, who certainly knows that a lot of mental health problems are caused by, (or aggravated by), drugs use (which Clegg wants to legalise and encourage) never mentions that issue.

  • David Booth.

    The Mental Health Services have been running down for the last forty years lured by the mirage of “Community Care” coupled to the supposed financial bonanza generated from the selling off of valuable building land the hospitals were built on. The hospitals have gone and so has the money raised by their sale which was supposed to be invested in improved services. It wasn’t.

Can't find your Web ID? Click here